See bottom of post for update.
I actually did an inspired by post with these J Crew's Darby glitter loafers a week or so ago. They retail for $215 and also come in pecan.
I just found the BEST option for less, and I'm super excited about it! These flats retail for $59.95 and only come in the pewter color shown. Just click on the photo to rush over and grab up a pair for yourself.
*Update - 10/18/11* - Here is a similar shoe (although not available in silver) from Go Jane which retails for $18.70. Click HERE if you're interested in purchasing.